Re: Blackberry as PDA
Greetings All...
I've been using Palm's for about 2 years, 3 months now. My first one was the M105. A nice chunk of memory, comfortable in the hand, and with enough options, like the Stowaway Keyboard, to show me the potential of the media.
At the end of last year, I had the opportunity to get the M515 for close to cost. I got one as gift for X-Mas; and after drooling over it and resisting the urge to open the box, play with it, and put it back in before the holidays (lol) I got one for myself.
At the beginning of this year my company issued a policy mandating that certain Project Managers carry Blackberries.
I've been walking around now for about 6 months with both devices, and I have to say that the Blackberry is excellent as a "reactive" device - keeping you in touch with the outside world, and putting out fires while they are still small. In terms of being "proactive" and organizing your life, I think the Palm is still the best. Palm has the advantage of color, superior organization through use of Categories, and a variety of ways to navigate the device so that you can either retrieve or capture info quickly.
The Blackerrys are limited by limited (or no) use of categories, a greyscale screen (which reminds me of my old M105, but worse); and only one main way to navigate - the "wheel." Plus, the third party software options are also limited. It is obvious from the device itself, that the developers primary goal was the e-mail/pager. The PIM parts of the device, were either released pre-maturely and not fully developed, or simply not the priority in their vision of the device.
A perfect marriage would be if RIM (the manufacturer) would license their software/hardware to Palm - so we could have the best of "proactive" and "reactive" in one piece of hardware. But then I'd only have one "holster" on my belt....
Now, if you'll excuse me - my Blackberry is vibrating....