A new motto?
ludlow said:
There's definitely one strain of personality type -- I'm not necessarily saying this includes you, feantur, but I think it does include me -- that wants to implement systems like GTD completely comprehensively, extending the logic of the system to its absolute limits, in a way that I would call perfectionistic and that can become pretty obsessive....
If you do have that obsessive/perfectionist streak, I think this is a direction it's worth trying to resist.
David Allen sometimes inadvertently encourages freaks like me in this unhelpful line of thinking when he talks about the importance of lists being comprehensive.
A number of points here resonate for me:
1) Re. obsessive/perfectionistic streaks: I consider myself a "recovering perfectionist." I've stopped beating myself up for being human, and I know the exact (ha ha) date and occasion when this happened. On Saturday, October 16, 2004, at the Regional Conference of NAPO-SFBA, I heard
Done is better than perfect.
Talk about a productivity enhancer!!!
2) A personality type that wants to implement GTD comprehensively should remind him/herself that "comprehensively" and "exhaustively" are different.
Talk about a productivity reducer!!!
3) I've read GTD, Ready for Anything, and listened to GTD Fast. My understanding of David Allen's reference to "comprehensive" is to be sure your areas of responsibility are captured in your trusted collection device (for me, a pad of paper). Now, for most of us, it may be the case that "brush teeth" doesn't need to be on a list--it's an ingrained behavior. But--and this varies by individual--the "areas of responsibility" which are ingrained vs. those which will niggle at the mind unless they are written down are the ones to capture; not every exhaustive action which you will undertake every day.
Only you will know when you've crossed the line from productive responsibility-capturing to a diminishing-returns quest for perfection.
(I hope this helps someone as much as
Done is better than perfect helped me. God, was that a freeing thing to hear!)
Cynthia