shtriemel said:
I'm curious...why is this method more effective than a PDA?
This is doesn't have to be an "Either/Or" proposition.
David Allen himself uses a PDA, laptop, and paper (he showed us his "stuff" at the seminar, and let us see his context-sorted to do lists--done in Lotus Notes--on the projector screen. For paper, he appears to really enjoy his Note-taker wallet, among other things.
In the book, DA recommends using one piece of paper per action *at the beginning*, when you are going through all of your stuff, figuring out "What is this", deciding on NA's, so that they later can be sorted by context.
I suspect that the benefit of having this stuff "in your face" in the form of paper, at the beginning, serves as a way to "show" us, in a very physically tangible manner, just how much "stuff" we have.
Also, when making such decisions, and recording info quickly and "on the fly" I have found personally, that it is physically *easier* and *faster* to write down this information on a piece of paper, before I "loose" the thought, than it is to enter it directly into a PDA. (I have since given up on PDA's and gone back to paper, but on the posts here and on 43 folders you will find people who use PDA's *and* paper.)
The main benefit of paper is its spontaneity--you don't have to turn it on, get into the right program first in order for you to enter input.
You are quite right that moving tasks from one list to another (later on, once they have already been captured) can indeed be easily done by a PDA or something like the GTD Outlook Add-in. After the data has been initially captured on paper, there is no reason not to put the information into a the desktop software that comes with the PDA, or into the PDA itself (the decision will depend on each person's preferred form of data-entry). Once that is done, you can get rid of the paper.
But for those of us who prefer paper, the single sheet really works great, not as just an initial place to right things down, but also as a way to follow a task through to completion as described in previous threads in this topic.
HTH!
~Cindy