Hi everyone,
I’ve been implementing GTD for about a month now, and while it initially helped me stay on top of tasks, I’ve hit a few roadblocks as my workload increased. I’d love to hear how more experienced practitioners handle these challenges.
What Worked Well Initially:
- The "capture everything" mindset reduced mental clutter.
- Processing my inbox daily gave me a sense of control.
- The "next actions" list helped me well.
Current Struggles:
- Inbox Overload – My collection rate now exceeds my processing capacity, leading to backlog stress.
- Energy Drain – When fatigued, I default to passive recovery (e.g., short videos) instead of meaningful rest or task completion.
- Task Resistance – New inputs (especially from peers/partners) trigger annoyance, partly because recording them feels like adding to an already overwhelming system.
- Urgent vs. GTD – Some unplanned urgent tasks bypass my system entirely, leaving me reactive.
Specific Questions:
- For those who’ve faced "collect > process" imbalance: How did you recalibrate?
- Any tips for maintaining motivation during low-energy phases?
- How do you handle externally assigned tasks without resentment?
- Do you integrate urgent "fire drills" into GTD, or keep them separate?
I’m committed to making GTD work but could use advice on refining my approach. Thanks in advance for your insights!
Thanks a lot for sharing your experience so openly — what you’re going through is extremely common among people who’ve just started implementing GTD more seriously. And it’s a great sign that you’re noticing these tensions; they show you’re engaging at the right level.
One insight from me that might be helpful:
Many new practitioners initially have a hard time fully clicking with what David Allen calls the Three-Fold Nature of Work — especially the part about consciously allocating time to “define work” (organizing, clarifying, reviewing), and not just “doing” work or “doing work as it shows up.”
For years, most of us have been conditioned to stay almost exclusively in “doing mode,” reacting to tasks as they appear, even if that doing wasn’t actually moving us meaningfully toward any desired outcomes. As your collection muscle strengthens (which it clearly has!), your system surfaces everything — and it’s normal to feel temporarily overwhelmed. It’s not that GTD is creating more work — it’s just exposing all the work that was always there but previously hidden in mental clutter.
A few thoughts on your specific struggles:
• Collect > Process Imbalance:
This is often a sign that it’s time to shift energy upwards — to strengthen the clarifying and organizing habits even more. Sometimes it’s not about processing everything daily, but about building a sustainable rhythm: maybe an emergency mini-clarifying pass at day’s end, plus deeper processing during a Weekly Review. Also, it’s okay to admit that some “captured” items are no longer relevant or can be deferred/sidelined.
• Energy Drain and Low Motivation:
It helps to keep a “Low Energy” context list — easy wins you can tackle when you’re fatigued (e.g., “browse ideas for vacation” or “clear 5 emails”). Also, recognize that real rest is as legitimate an action as any task. Planning for meaningful recovery is absolutely part of GTD.
• Externally Assigned Tasks and Resentment:
When a new request comes in, treating it as just another input to clarify objectively (“What is this? What’s the next action?”) can create a bit of emotional distance. It’s not about the person, it’s about the item. And if it truly doesn’t belong to you, GTD also gives you tools to renegotiate commitments. « Getting rid of the monkey on your shoulders »
• Handling Urgent Fire Drills:
Fire drills are part of life. Ideally, you capture them too — but in truly urgent situations, it’s okay to act first and record later. GTD is flexible, not rigid. After the storm, it’s important to realign by re-trusting your lists and your Weekly Review.
Bottom line: you’re not doing GTD wrong — you’re facing the natural growing pains that come with building real self-management capacity. Stick with it, and it’ll pay off.
Happy to dive deeper into any of these if it would help!