For the record, I have had lots of procrastination problems myself, and have read a zillion books about it, often as a way to procrastinate further!
I consider "avoidance" and procrastination the same thing, I have even created a special GTD category called !ANTIAVOIDANCE, which lists the Next Actions I am resisting, avoiding and procrastinating. (sadly, I often AVOID looking at this list! The mind is a tricky thing.)
But, that being said, even a 50,000-ft mountain of procrastination, or even a literal technical PHOBIA, that blocks people in an extreme way, can only be overcome in this way.
People have tried everything, from hypnosis, to chanting, to praying, to magic spells, etc, etc.
But in the end, it is going to come down to some type of tiny Behavioral Next Action moving ONE STEP in that direction.
If one looks at the current treatments for extreme phobias, for example, the first step after figuring out what is going on, is to do mental exposure, and to IMAGINE yourself doing the action. This is actually the first Next Action, even though it is mental.
But it is part of a hierarchy of actions, from tiny, going on up to more difficult.
An example would be a fear of flying, as a fist step, you would get in your car and drive past the airport, and look at the planes. Over a period of weeks, that Next Action increases by a tiny step by step, one small step at a time, until you are actually having coffee in the airport, boarding planes that do not take off as part of a Fear of Flying program, etc. Over a period of time you EXTINGUISH the emotive response that is blocking you from flying through graded behavioral exposure. As you EXPOSE yourelf to the situation, the emotions begin to calm down over many exposures.
In my mind, this applies to all forms of procrastination I can think of, as well. So again, I am opposed to "Just Do It", unless of course you can do that. Its usually better to isolate that tiny specific Next Action, and then DO that, until its not a problem anymore, and then you move on carefully to the next step.
A great book that explains all this is...
The Anxiety & Phobia Workbook: by Edmund J. Bourne
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/15...102-9353852-7829716?s=books&v=glance&n=283155
Again, I cannot see or imagine an example where it is not going to boil down to doing some tiny Next Action that moves you in the direction you want to go. That is what is great about GTD and procrastination, defining the Next Action is the critical step, but then its going to take some type of PUSH to get that action done. There is no other way, and believe me, I have tried them all. If its a serious problem, its best to have a trained psychologist help you work through it, in terms of Behavior Therapy.
The interesting thing to me, is that this applies from the most grandiose of personal projects, to the most difficult procrastination and even mental health issues.
For example, for someone who is clinically depressed and can't get out of bed, the Next Action is "move your arm". The next one might be "move your leg", with the Outcome being "walk across the room", and then they build from there, with the help of a psychologist.
So it seems to me, that across the broadest area of human behavior, it boils down to the GTD idea of defining that specific behavioral Next Action.
The one area for me anyway, that is a little bit missing in GTD, is that sometimes, even after the Next Action is properly defined, we need to PUSH ourselves to do it. (Behavioral Forcing). We often have the idea that if the Next Action is properly defined, that we will automatically do it, or "feel like" doing it. The psychological literature states this is not the case at all, and as a matter of fact, is very often not the case.
The amazing thing is that if we can learn how to give ourselves that PUSH, to "make" ourselves DO the defined Next Action at a precise time, and use penalties and rewards for this, we can break the back of procrastination.
Does it always work, forever?
No way.
But for me anyway, I know that no matter what it is that is causing me trouble, that once the Next Action behavior is properly defined, that it is going to take a PUSH to do it. If the Next Action is small enough, then it is doable.
Again, I have wracked my brain over this, and cannot think of an exception, discounting someone with severe mental illness. (but even in those cases, the treatments often are this type of very simple Behavior Therapy)
flexiblefine said:
CosmoGTD is not expressing this view as someone who sees his own procrastination as a powerful force that will be difficult to overthrow. For those of us in that position, "just do it" sounds a little contemptuous. "Just do it" doesn't show any respect for the 50,000-foot mountain we feel like we have to climb to overcome our problems.
There's no other way of doing things but to do them. You can't ask a pretty girl out for a Saturday evening without actually doing it, and you can't do the things you've been putting off until tomorrow without picking a step and doing it.
For those of us who have turned tasks into 50,000-foot mountains, we have to keep trying, step by step, until we learn that focus dissolves difficulty, and it's really not that bad in the end. (The mountain, after all, is imaginary.) But it's an ongoing process.