Some thoughts on this part 1 (very verbose- sorry!)
Hi Trish,
I think I'm someone who gets so wrapped up in the tools, I lose the system, so it sounds like me and thee have a couple of things in common. It
is all about the habits. There's no way of getting around it. We've got to buckle down, put noses to grindstones, gird loins, and all those other metaphors for making ourselves do things that we might not like.
That said, there are workarounds for many things. I'll describe my system first, so you know where I'm coming from. I'm a professional organiser, so I'm either working with clients, at my computer, or generally out and about, which constrains my work/system as follows:
1) I use a small diary/organiser for appointments, so it's the hard landscape with extras (like clients' addresses with each appointment). That has to travel with me, but it's almost the only thing that does.
2) My ubiquitous capture tools (UCTs) are small spiral bound notebooks (out and about) or loose paper (home): each Thing That Pops Into My Head gets written down, then tossed into my...
3) In tray, which is the top drawer of a 10-drawer mobile unit in my study/office. It's semi-transparent, so I can see that stuff's in there, but not well enough to scare me.
4) From there, the Stuff gets processed into a small desktop 5-drawer thingie as projects, each on a loose sheet of A4 paper. These trays are: Nice and Nasty (projects that are active this week), Foot-Tapping (Waiting for), Ignoring (things that will be done soonish), and Dreaming (someday/maybe).
5) I've recently changed my context list format, because, like you, I'd look at a half-finished list and I'd just groan and run away to hide in the wardrobe. So now my context lists are held thus:
5a) out and about lists are kept in the hacker PDA/UCT;
5b) phone lists are on paper, because it's quite possible to crank through the whole lot in one sitting;
5c) everything else is in The New Format, which I'll explain in a mo.
6) At the moment, I've got the Action/Waiting/Pending folders in my email, and an Archive folder. This has some problems, which I'll talk about in a separate post.
The New Format: each NA is written on a sticky, which is stuck inside a folder. When the NA is done, the sticky goes, so the 'list' stays fairly pristine. If you like, you can rearrange them in an order that reflects priorities, because stickies are infinitely moveable. And the folder can be closed at the end of the day so it looks neat.
I'm mostly paper, because I've done the excitement-with-tech-toys thing and I'm well into the stage of thorough-disgust-with-tech-toys. The learning curve is way too steep, and these days I can't even be bothered to learn to use the things I have (hey, the manuals are filed in my file drawers under M ;-)). Paper is
easy: there's no learning curve, and it's also bare-bones enough that it shows up problems in my implementation without interference from tetchy software (don't get me started!).