S
SoftwareGuy
Guest
After doing GTD for a while, I fell off the wagon. In the process of getting back on, I started to seriously question how effective GTD really is. My biggest concern is that the most important projects may not get the most attention in GTD. A second concern is that GTD takes a lot of administrative overhead.
GTD says that scheduling your workday in advance is unrealistic because everything is changing all the time and your task priorities change, too. This really resonated with me at first. But if you have 200 next actions, how are you supposed to pick the best next thing to work on? Looking at a huge list many times during the day is demoralizing. I also feel that GTD encourages collecting too many todos. Maybe this issue has nothing to do with GTD, but the idea of writing down everything all the time grows lists massively, at least for me. Regular purging is a way to keep them shorter, but this means a lot of time reviewing each week.
But the biggest problem is that the GTD NA list-processing algorithm does not necessarily structure your work time very well. In contrast, blocking out massive amounts of time each week in advance for important projects can net big dividends.
As an alternative to GTD, I have been thinking about trying the Planner Pad organizer (https://plannerpads.com/) or something similar. I have been doing GTD on a Palm, so this would be a big change. I like the idea of having a weekly view. I like the idea of having projects at the top that show me constantly the big stuff that I want to accomplish this week. I like the idea of having a small (that is, realistic) number of daily todos. I like the idea of having the calendar there, too.
When I first looked at the Planner Pad, I thought, wow, I could never fit all the stuff I have to do on this. But then I thought about the fact that a lot of the stuff I put in GTD never gets done, either, due to lack of time. (I know that you can move it to the someday/maybe list, but somehow this does not seem right to me, or at least a little depressing.) Having a limited amount of space on the Planner Pad might force me to be more realistic on the front end. And also focus my week on what is really important.
What do you all think?
GTD says that scheduling your workday in advance is unrealistic because everything is changing all the time and your task priorities change, too. This really resonated with me at first. But if you have 200 next actions, how are you supposed to pick the best next thing to work on? Looking at a huge list many times during the day is demoralizing. I also feel that GTD encourages collecting too many todos. Maybe this issue has nothing to do with GTD, but the idea of writing down everything all the time grows lists massively, at least for me. Regular purging is a way to keep them shorter, but this means a lot of time reviewing each week.
But the biggest problem is that the GTD NA list-processing algorithm does not necessarily structure your work time very well. In contrast, blocking out massive amounts of time each week in advance for important projects can net big dividends.
As an alternative to GTD, I have been thinking about trying the Planner Pad organizer (https://plannerpads.com/) or something similar. I have been doing GTD on a Palm, so this would be a big change. I like the idea of having a weekly view. I like the idea of having projects at the top that show me constantly the big stuff that I want to accomplish this week. I like the idea of having a small (that is, realistic) number of daily todos. I like the idea of having the calendar there, too.
When I first looked at the Planner Pad, I thought, wow, I could never fit all the stuff I have to do on this. But then I thought about the fact that a lot of the stuff I put in GTD never gets done, either, due to lack of time. (I know that you can move it to the someday/maybe list, but somehow this does not seem right to me, or at least a little depressing.) Having a limited amount of space on the Planner Pad might force me to be more realistic on the front end. And also focus my week on what is really important.
What do you all think?