Personally I prefer Digital Tickler list than a calendar – please check my below remarks:
- You may find it a little messy when you aggregate tickler items, day-specific actions and day-specific information all as the calendar all-day events.
- You may find it more handy to review tickler items as a list - especially if you want to make some changes.
- It is easier to miss or skip a tickler item when you put in the calendar. You will rather not miss anything when you keep it on the list - overdue items will be visible on top of your list.
- List tickler items are hidden and “appear” when the times come – and it is closer to original idea of 43 folders and “clearing” your view and your head.
In the other hand most of popular tools like Microsoft To Do or Todoist do not offer separate start dates and due dates – and in my opinion in such a situation it is better to keep tickler items in the calendar and due date items in the list manager.
You can make a very good implementation of the tickler file in the Outlook Tasks (but it is complicated to set). Quite good implementation of tickler file you can also find in Nirvana – but there is a little trap – there is one and the same list for tickler and for “focus” items (I think it is better to use it only for one purpose, not for both). Also FacileThings solved it quite well – you can see tickler items as a list and at the same time in your calendar and you can also quickly hide tickler items in your calendar.